Election 2024: Is Trump Truly Comparable to Hitler?

Trump’s Authoritarian Playbook: Why He’s a Grave Threat to American Democracy

Many sources on the internet have information about the various ways in which Trump is like (and unlike) Hitler. I wanted to know if ChatGPT4 would steer my more specific questions/prompts back to generality as in ChatGP3. The answer is, it doesn’t.

In fact, I did not have to change names or use hypothetical situations at all. So, I freely used the words “Trump” “Biden” “Hitler” “Godwin’s Law” “Politics” etc. The final result (after 8 increasingly specific prompts) begins after the quote.

Writing this in under 30 minutes freaked me out a little, I’m not gonna lie.

“There are numerous disturbing ways in which Trump has emulated elements of Hitler’s campaigns and propaganda. Additionally, there are similarities in how the ideologies of their parties have manifested, as well as a consistent issue of violence and hatred present within their agendas and their supporters.” Populism: A Comparative Study of the Rise of the Alt-Right in Germany and the United States Germany and the United States- Kate O. Tobin/Butler University.

AI ChatGPT4—edited

“In a world where history often repeats itself, it’s important to understand how leaders can use similar tactics to gain and maintain power. Donald Trump’s approach to governing has raised alarm bells because it bears striking similarities to the methods used by Adolf Hitler and his inner circle, like Joseph Goebbels, Trump has worked to manipulate public opinion, consolidate power, and undermine democratic institutions. These comparisons are NOT about the Holocaust, but about how dictators rise to power, using deceit and division. This is why many believe Trump represents a profound danger to American democracy.

One of the most alarming tactics used by both Trump and Hitler is their manipulation of the media and use of propaganda. Hitler’s Propaganda Minister, Joseph Goebbels, was a master at controlling the narrative. He used radio broadcasts, films, posters, and mass rallies to spread Nazi ideology and demonize opponents. This created a cult of personality around Hitler, making him seem like the only leader who could save Germany. Trump, while not using a formal propaganda ministry, similarly attacked the mainstream media, calling it “fake news” and “the enemy of the people.” By doing this, Trump tried to discredit news outlets that criticized him and create a direct line to his supporters through social media. His rallies, filled with fiery speeches and nationalist rhetoric, mirrored the mass gatherings orchestrated by Goebbels.

Trump’s consistent efforts to undermine democratic institutions are another cause for concern. Hitler quickly dismantled Germany’s democratic structures after becoming Chancellor. He used the Reichstag Fire as a pretext to pass laws that suspended civil liberties and gave him dictatorial powers. Trump’s relentless claims of widespread voter fraud in the 2020 election, despite no substantial evidence, were seen as a direct attack on the electoral process. His refusal to concede and the subsequent incitement of the January 6th Capitol riot were unprecedented assaults on American democracy.

Scapegoating and division are also tactics that Trump has used, similar to Hitler. Hitler blamed Jews, communists, and other groups for Germany’s problems, creating a common enemy to unify his base. Trump has frequently targeted immigrants, particularly from Latin America and Muslim-majority countries, blaming them for crime and economic issues. This rhetoric fostered a dangerous “us versus them” mentality among his supporters. By stoking these divisions, Trump not only polarized the nation but also diverted attention from broader systemic issues.

The creation of a cult of personality is another tactic shared by Trump and Hitler. Hitler was portrayed as Germany’s savior, a messianic figure destined to restore the nation’s greatness. Trump similarly cultivated a fiercely loyal following, branding himself as an outsider who could “drain the swamp.” His rallies were characterized by passionate support and a strong sense of unity among attendees. This personal loyalty often translated into unwavering support, regardless of Trump’s actions or statements.

Both Hitler and Trump exploited economic and social discontent to gain support. Hitler capitalized on the Great Depression and the widespread despair in post-World War I Germany, promising economic revival and national rejuvenation. Trump tapped into the frustrations of working-class and rural Americans who felt left behind by globalization and technological change. By addressing their grievances and positioning himself as their champion, Trump secured a strong voter base. This manipulation of economic anxiety is a common tactic among authoritarian leaders seeking to consolidate power.

Trump’s presidency saw numerous attacks on the rule of law, drawing uncomfortable parallels to Hitler’s regime. Hitler’s systematic dismantling of legal protections and use of the judiciary to serve Nazi interests were key to his consolidation of power. Trump’s repeated attacks on judges who ruled against his policies, his pardoning of allies, and attempts to interfere with ongoing investigations raised significant concerns about his respect for legal norms. These actions undermined the foundational principles of accountability and justice that are crucial to a functioning democracy.

Another dangerous similarity is the mobilization of extremist groups. Hitler relied on paramilitary organizations like the SA (Sturmabteilung) to intimidate opponents and enforce Nazi policies. These groups played a crucial role in his rise to power by using violence and intimidation to suppress dissent and rally support. Trump has been accused of indirectly encouraging extremist groups, particularly those involved in the January 6th Capitol riot. His rhetoric, including statements that appeared to endorse or excuse the actions of far-right groups, has been seen as emboldening these organizations. The presence of militias and extremist factions at his rallies and events has raised concerns about the potential for political violence.

In summary, while the historical contexts and outcomes of their actions differ, the authoritarian tactics employed by Donald Trump bear alarming similarities to those of Adolf Hitler and his inner circle. By manipulating media, undermining democratic institutions, scapegoating minorities, and fostering a cult of personality, Trump has demonstrated a dangerous disregard for democratic norms and principles. As Americans reflect on the fragility of their democracy, it is crucial to recognize these patterns and safeguard against the rise of authoritarianism. The lessons of history are clear: unchecked power and divisive rhetoric can lead to the erosion of democracy and the rise of tyranny. Recognizing these similarities and understanding their implications is essential for preserving the democratic foundations of the United States.”

A few references:

https://www.mediaite.com/print/godwins-law-creator-justifies-trump-hitler-comparisons-in-searing-column-the-parallels-seem-inescapable/

https://digitalcommons.butler.edu/bjur/vol10/iss1/5

https://www.politico.com/news/magazine/2023/12/19/godwins-law-trump-hitler-00132427

https://link.springer.com/book/10.1007/978-3-031-51833-1